Mediation in the Middle East: Bridging the Past with the Present

October 2, 2023

In the bustling markets and ancient cities of the Middle East, the art of mediation has long been a thread woven deeply into the fabric of society. This age-old practice, deeply rooted in Arab and Islamic traditions, has shaped the way disputes are resolved, balancing the old with the new in a region rich in history and culture.

A Journey Through Time: The Origins of Middle Eastern Mediation

Imagine a time hundreds of years ago when the Prophet Muhammad, revered by many, was chosen by feuding tribes to resolve a dispute over the reconstruction of the Ka’ba. His ingenious solution, benefitting all parties, is an early testament to the power of mediation. This story symbolizes the deep historical roots of mediation in Middle Eastern culture, where it has been practiced as an integral part of society for centuries.

Islamic law, or Sharia, endorses the concept of an independent mediator through practices like Al Wasata. Picture a respected individual stepping in, offering solutions to conflicting parties – a scenario strikingly similar to modern-day mediation. The rituals of sulh (settlement) and musalaha (reconciliation), integral to the region, further illustrate this tradition. In these rituals, conflicts are resolved not just at an individual level but within the community, emphasizing the collective over the individual.

Mediation Today: Adapting to a Modern Landscape

Fast forward to the present, and you’ll find that mediation remains a preferred method of dispute resolution in the Middle East. Contemporary Islamic law encourages mediation, reflecting its historical roots. Countries like Jordan and the United Arab Emirates have established legal frameworks for mediation, demonstrating its continued relevance.

In Dubai, for instance, the Mediation Centre established under Dubai Law No. 16 of 2009, and the DIFC-LCIA Arbitration Centre, offer mediation services that blend modern dispute resolution with traditional practices. Qatar’s International Center for Conciliation and Arbitration follows a similar path, showcasing the region’s commitment to adapting mediation for today’s disputes.

The Unique Role of the Mediator in the Middle East

What sets Middle Eastern mediation apart is the role of the mediator. Unlike their Western counterparts, who are neutral facilitators, Middle Eastern mediators are seen as wise figures with solutions. They command respect and often adopt a more active and evaluative role, focusing on restoring relationships and maintaining social harmony. This approach reflects a cultural emphasis on collective well-being over individual interests.

East Meets West: Contrasting Approaches to Mediation

In the West, mediation is often an alternative to court proceedings, but in the Middle East, it frequently complements formal legal processes. While discretion is key in both approaches, Middle Eastern mediators might find themselves testifying in court about the agreements reached, a scenario less likely in the West.

Additionally, the conformity of mediation agreements with Sharia law adds another layer of complexity. Restrictions against riba (usury) and gharar (uncertainty, akin to gambling) pose unique challenges, making the application of mediation in commercial disputes particularly intricate.

Mediation and the Rise of E-Sports in the Middle East

Now, let’s turn to a contemporary context where mediation is gaining ground – the rapidly growing world of e-sports. With its surging popularity in the Middle East, the potential for disputes in this dynamic industry is significant. From player transfers to broadcasting rights, e-sports present a new frontier for mediation.

In the UAE and other GCC countries, sports disputes, including those in e-sports, typically go to arbitration. This process is defined by relevant agreements and regulations, with disciplinary decisions often subject to appeal through arbitration bodies at various levels, reflecting international practices.

Looking Ahead: Mediation’s Evolving Role in the Middle East

Despite its rich history and cultural significance, the Middle East hasn’t seen a surge in the use of institutional mediation processes. This may be due to the limited number of trained mediators and a lack of trust in their impartiality. However, with the region’s increasing involvement in global sports industries, including e-sports, the need for effective dispute resolution mechanisms is more pressing than ever.

As the Middle East continues to blend its rich traditions with modern practices, the role of mediation is poised to expand. By addressing the current challenges and building on its historical and cultural strengths, mediation in the Middle East can continue to be a vital tool in resolving disputes, from ancient tribal conflicts to modern-day e-sports controversies.

Contact detailsDauerman Sports Mediation Center Foundation
ul. Powstańców Śląskich 9
53-332 Wrocław
Let's stay in touchWe invite!
Contact detailsDauerman Sports Mediation Center Foundation
ul. Powstańców Śląskich 9
53-332 Wrocław
What you will findMenu
Let's stay in touchWe invite!

2023 Copyright by SMC. All rights reserved.